I only have 5 copies of the book right now, so I used a document camera to project the pages. I wasn't quite sure where I was going to go with this simple chapter, and the magic happened! I really focused on questioning the students about every sentence or two. Here are some of the questions I asked, based on the first chapter of the book:
- How old was Isabelle's mom when she had her?
- Do you think that's young to have a baby?
- What is the perfect age to have a baby?
- Am I, at 38, too old to have a baby?
- Would you like to have a baby at 17?
- If her mom is brunette with brown eyes, what do you think her dad looks like?
- (and here, someone suggested she might have been adopted) Could her mom have adopted her at 20? (then, someone suggested she could have adopted her as an older child when she was older or Isabelle could have been kidnapped.)
- Do any of you have a parent who travels a lot for work?
- Who the heck still uses a real camera?
- Who wants to be famous?
- Do famous vets exist?
- How about famous dancers? (then we named some)
- Can you be a famous dancer and then be president?
The higher-order thinking was off the hook and when we finished the chapter in my afternoon class, a student said "Can we keep reading that book? It was really fun."
I have to admit that I honestly thought that teachers who quoted their students saying similar things in the past lived in a utopia where every student is the child of a college professor or something. Now that it's happening in my class, I'm astounded!
In my IB level 2 first days, we read this and created background for plot holes and missing info We did this for Pauvre Anne as well (did it like a choose your own adventure). I forgot we did this. Might recapture this idea and do this in my Honors 3/4 to start out. hmmmm
ReplyDeleteHere is a link to the chapitre supplementaire for ch 1... https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gN6KOPSf1f20KlpM4wz09pPDjC8gEHLE/view?usp=sharing
DeleteIs there a movie talk that could be used for Isabelle? I'm trying to find one. Thx
ReplyDeleteYou know, I'm not really sure. Anyone else out there know of one?
DeleteThank you for sharing this! It helped me realize the power of "what isn't said?" and "what's missing" to engage students in better discussions.
ReplyDeleteDid you assess students at the end of the book? If so, how?
HI I just stumbled across your blog, I really like that idea of higher order questions. Not something I would have thought of on my own, but worth it.
ReplyDelete