Wednesday, November 7, 2012

The stress of the last month

I have been trying to think of how to compose this blog and avoiding it because it just makes me feel bad...

About a month ago, we had a district-wide meeting of all the language teachers.  We were talking about common core and how to support the ELA and math teachers in our classes.  Great stuff.  The problem came when we got together with our languages to talk about how things have been going.  My TPRS colleague and I were attacked by our non-TPRS (and upper-level) colleagues.  We were told that we aren't teaching our students anything (okay, I can kind of ignore that because I know what my kids can do), that we have to use the book (again, I can ignore that because there is nothing that says I have to use a textbook), and that the parents and students are complaining that they weren't prepared by us to continue to the next level (this is the one that stung).  They complained and attacked for around 45 minutes while my colleague and I answered their attacks.

 "Do your kids ever see a verb chart?"  "No."  "Well, I think they are a very handy tool because, once they have seen a verb chart, they can conjugate almost any verb that they find in a dictionary." 

"Can your kids count and say the alphabet?" (this one was just ridiculous)

"It's October: have your kids learned avoir?"  "They have learned how to say I have, you have, and he/she has"  "Well, if they haven't learned the other forms, what else are you teaching them in that time?"  "My kids know reads, listens to, plays, is, writes, sleeps, knows, etc etc"  "But they only know the singular forms of those..."

This went on forever.  Finally, as we were running out of time, an administrator came to check in with us and the "leader" (who has no power over us besides that she teaches the highest level) said that we needed more time to collaborate and could we have the afternoon together.

And so it continued...  Although I do have to say that the afternoon was much more productive since we actually talked about what we teach in each level and what the high school teachers consider essential and what they consider extra.  Turns out that we agree on most of it.  The difference is that the high school teachers teach songs to help them conjugate all the forms, while we teach our kids to actually use the language.  But it was actually productive and I felt good after that.

But now I don't feel good anymore.  I am constantly questioning myself.  "Am I really teaching them anything?"  "But in their free writes, they are making so many spelling and conjugation errors!"  "Man, they are supposed to learn imparfait, passe compose and conditionnel in one year?!  How am I going to make sure that they can fill out those boxes?"

I don't want to think like this.  I want to point out that Stephen Krashen sent an email to moreTPRS saying that what I'm doing in the classroom is right.  I want to print off the new ACTFL guidelines and show them how I'm meeting them.  I want them to at least spend an HOUR in my classroom before they attack me.  They have NO CLUE what I do down here!!!  But instead, I can't get out of my head.  I keep envisioning my awesome students from last year, whom I led, taught, and loved, sitting in a classroom and taking a test that they fail because I didn't teach them to fill in boxes last year.  It breaks my heart.  I feel like I can't look my students in the eyes because I know what they are going to have to do next year.  And I don't want them to blame me for failing them. 

Help.  I need help.  I'm better than this.  I am a damn good teacher.  I know it.  But the little voice in my head is confused.  Do I take a week/month at the end of the year and work through the textbook so they won't be unprepared?  I will NOT stop teaching this way because I LOVE it and my students love it.  I am reaching students every day who are failing other classes and hate school. 

Phew!  That was a lot to dump on you, dear reader (if you exist), but I had to get my thoughts out so that I can hopefully feel better.  If you have any ideas (particularly with those tricky conditional endings), let me know...

3 comments:

  1. Oh Bess, even though I'm not in the classroom anymore I totally feel for you. If I had stayed, I was going to jump on the TPRS bandwagon too because I agree that it IS the right way. You are an awesome teacher and your kids DO know so much. I think the high school teachers should come to your classroom--did you suggest they do that? Maybe if they came and saw what your kids could do they'd change their tune a little. I was definitely sold when I came and observed!! Anyway, take it with a grain of salt from a no-longer-teaching gal, but I think you should keep doing what you're doing. You are awesome :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I exist! Everything you said that could be a response to your non-TPRS colleagues is exactly what you need to remember. Your students actually use the language. I am incredibly lucky to be at a small school with administration and department support, but can imagine your position. I got my first teaching job when a teacher quit (after 20 years) because the department chair told her she could not use TPRS. Incredible! Can you get your administration on your side? A few more colleagues? Every ally counts but you'll never convince them all.

    I'd be totally honest with my students about the way they should expect to learn a language once they get to the high school. I'm not a total purist convert to TPRS, but I'd do three days at the almost end of the year to teach them about those very conjugation charts. Maybe even do the high school teachers' songs. I most certainly believe TPRS is best for kids but you've got to deal with the reality of a different structure and instructor. If you're willing to give a little in terms of the grammar (just don't mention how very little), your critics might even thank you for the wonderful skills your students bring to the next level. My guess is if you did 3 days of grammar your top 10% would remember that to move on - and how would that be different from a traditional language classroom?

    Best of luck from a friend in Iowa, Kristin

    ReplyDelete
  3. I exist too!! These ladies have given great advice. I could talk for days about this....let me know if you want to email/chat....lclarcq@rochester.rr.com

    with love,
    Laurie

    ReplyDelete